Comparison
Chutes vs. LibertAI: AI privacy, models & price
-
chutes.ai7 Nov 2026 Image source Source chutes.ai Retrieved on Logos and product pictures are trademarks of their owners and are shown for identification only. ChutesChutes
-
docs.libertai.io7 Nov 2026
Image source
Source
docs.libertai.io
Retrieved on
Logos and product pictures are trademarks of their owners and are shown for identification only.
LibertAILibertAI
In short
- Least KYC: LibertAI (No KYC required).
- LibertAI has the best score (6.5).
- Chutes leads in Trust.
- LibertAI leads in Privacy, Features.
| Attribute | ChutesChutes | LibertAILibertAI |
|---|---|---|
| Overview | Occasional KYC · no personal data | No KYC · no personal data |
| Score | 4.8 | 6.5 with variant Plus: 6.0 with variant Max: 5.6 |
| Privacy | 4.4 | 7.8 |
| Security | 0.0 | 0.0 |
| Trust | 6.1 | 5.6 |
| Costs | not scored | 8.5 |
| Features | 6.0 | 6.5 |
| Community | not scored | not scored |
| Score factors that differ | ||
| Plus KYC policy | Occasional KYC3 of 5 | No KYC required5 of 5 |
| Plus Chats kept on the server | Until you delete0 of 8 | Only on your device8 of 8 |
| Plus Who processes your prompts | Partner hosts2.5 of 5 | Own servers5 of 5 |
| Plus Sign-up over Tor/VPN | Blocked0 of 2 | not sourced0 of 2 |
| Plus Legal seat | United States0.4 of 2 | France0.8 of 2 |
| Plus Two-factor login | not published0 of 5 | not sourced0 of 5 |
| Plus Operating since | since 20242.87 of 6 | since 20234.27 of 6 |
| Plus Domain age | since 20242.39 of 3 | not sourced0 of 3 |
| Minus Domain bought from a previous owner | not sourcedno deduction (up to −2) | nono deduction (up to −2) |
| Plus Typical yearly cost | does not applynot counted | 105.29 USD a year8.49 of 10 |
| Plus Web search | not published0 of 1 | yes1 of 1 |
| Note Uncensored models | not published | not sourced |
| Basics | ||
| Servicesame for all |
a chat app, an API
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Chutes Global Corp., a Delaware corporation ("Chutes," "we," "us," or "our"), provides this Privacy Policy to explain how we collect, use, disclose, retain, and protect personal data when you use chut...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
a chat app, an API
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
Yes. The chat at chat.libertai.io is free, no account needed. LiberClaw's free tier runs two always-on agents, no card required. The API has no minimum: top up a few dollars and pay only for the token...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Appssame for all |
Web
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Powered by Chutes - The world's top Open-Source Decentralized AI Compute Platform.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Web
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
The services comprise the libertai.io website, the chat application (chat.libertai.io), the console (console.libertai.io), the inference API and the search service.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Free tier (differs)same for all |
No
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
We do not offer a free tier at this time. Top up your account in the app to get started. Pay-as-you-go has no minimum commitment.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Yes
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
Yes. The chat at chat.libertai.io is free, no account needed. LiberClaw's free tier runs two always-on agents, no card required. The API has no minimum: top up a few dollars and pay only for the token...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Money-back guaranteesame for all |
not applicable
chutes.ai checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
12.3 Cryptocurrency payments. Cryptocurrency payments are final and nonrefundable. You are responsible for sending each blockchain transaction to the correct address, and Chutes is not responsible for...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| Termination without noticesame for all |
No
chutes.ai checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
16.2 By us. We may suspend or terminate your account or your access to any part of the Platform, immediately where reasonably necessary and otherwise with reasonable notice, if you breach these Terms,...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
No
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
LibertAI may terminate access in the event of a breach of these terms, after a formal notice that has remained without effect, except in the case of a serious breach justifying immediate suspension. W...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Anonymity | ||
| Sign-up needssame for all |
no e-mail and no phone number
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Pick a username — we'll mint a fingerprint you can sign in with.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
no e-mail and no phone number
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
An account created with a wallet contains neither an email address nor any legal identity.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Sign-up over Tor/VPNsame for all |
blocked
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Chutes is a United States company and must comply with United States sanctions and export control laws. To do so, we use your IP address, approximate location, account and organization data, payment d...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? History What does [s] mean? |
|
| ID check (differs)same for all |
an ID check on suspicion
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
- Verification and compliance data. Where the law requires it for sanctions screening, fraud prevention, or tax purposes, identity and organization information such as legal name, address, and ownersh...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
no ID check
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
Two ways: a subscription for regular usage, or prepaid credits billed per million tokens. Usage past a plan's allowance bills at the same per-token rate. Card or crypto, no seats, no KYC.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| ID on demand in the termssame for all |
No
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
- Verification and compliance data. Where the law requires it for sanctions screening, fraud prevention, or tax purposes, identity and organization information such as legal name, address, and ownersh...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| Your chats & data | ||
| Chats stored on the server (differs)same for all |
stored until you delete them
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Our first party applications store content when storage is part of the product. For example, Chutes Chat stores your conversation history so you can return to it, and Chutes Search may store your quer...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
stored only on your device
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
The chat application stores locally, in your browserand not on our servers: your conversation history and associated attachments, your assistants, projects and memories, your generated images, and you...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Training on your chatssame for all |
never used for training
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Our agreements with the Model Providers that serve Standard Models do not permit them to use your Inputs or Outputs to train, fine tune, or improve their models without our separate consent, and we do...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
never used for training
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
We do not use your data to train models, and we neither sell nor rent it to anyone.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Who processes your prompts (differs)same for all |
partner inference hosts
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Many Standard Models are served by established third party inference platforms ("Model Providers"), which run the Model on their own infrastructure. When you use one of these Models, Chutes sends your...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
only the provider's own servers
docs.libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
docs.libertai.io
Wording at the source
1. The load balancer at api.libertai.io — routes your request to a compute node. 2. The CRN (computing resource node) — runs the inference VM. 3. The inference VM — receives your prompt, runs the mode...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? History What does [s] mean? |
| Confidential computing (TEE)same for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Pay per token. No subscription, no minimum, no markup. Models marked run on confidential TEE compute.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Yes
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
Every model runs with nothing stored and nothing trained on your data. For sensitive workloads you do not have to take our word for it: TEE-served models like Hermes 3 8B run inside hardware-sealed en...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Data handed out without a court ordersame for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
authorities, where valid legal process compels disclosure, or where disclosure is reasonably necessary to comply with law, enforce our Terms, prevent fraud or abuse, or protect the rights, property, o...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| Data shared with third parties (differs)same for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
8.2 Analytics and advertising. We use Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics to understand how visitors use chutes.ai, and we may use Google advertising tags to measure the effectiveness of our adver...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
No
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
We do not use your data to train models, and we neither sell nor rent it to anyone.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Policy on authority requests published (differs)same for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Government requests. We require valid legal process before we disclose customer data, we read requests narrowly, and we object to overbroad demands. Where the law allows, we notify the affected custom...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
No
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
In the event of a breach, LibertAI may suspend or terminate access, without prejudice to any other remedy. Serious breaches may be reported to the competent authorities.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Account security | ||
| Two-factor loginsame for all |
not published
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
role based access controls, multifactor authentication for administrative access, and an incident response process. No system is completely secure, and we cannot promise that the Platform will never b...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 12 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| Models & features | ||
| Frontier modelssame for all |
–
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Chutes is a decentralized, serverless inference platform for open-source AI models.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 12 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
–
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
GLM-5.3 leads, with open models behind the same endpoint: Qwen, Gemma, DeepSeek, Hermes and more, plus image generation, embeddings, speech and private web search. All open-weight, so nothing can be d...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Open-weight modelssame for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V3.2-TEEChecked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Yes
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
GLM-5.3 leads, with open models behind the same endpoint: Qwen, Gemma, DeepSeek, Hermes and more, plus image generation, embeddings, speech and private web search. All open-weight, so nothing can be d...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Uncensored modelssame for all |
not published
chutes.ai checked 12 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Discover and compare all 32 public models on Chutes. Each model page lists its pricing and how to call it through the API.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 12 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 12 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| OpenAI-compatible APIsame for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
$ curl \Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Yes
docs.libertai.io checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
docs.libertai.io
Wording at the source
The /v1/chat/completions, /v1/completions, /v1/responses, and /v1/models endpoints are all OpenAI-compatible. /v1/messages is Anthropic-compatible.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Image generationsame for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 13 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Z-Image Turbo: fast text-to-image generationChecked Verified Check overdue · last 13 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Yes
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
GLM-5.3 leads, with open models behind the same endpoint: Qwen, Gemma, DeepSeek, Hermes and more, plus image generation, embeddings, speech and private web search. All open-weight, so nothing can be d...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Web search (differs)same for all |
not published
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
For example, Chutes Chat stores your conversation history so you can return to it, and Chutes Search may store your query history.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 12 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Yes
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
GLM-5.3 leads, with open models behind the same endpoint: Qwen, Gemma, DeepSeek, Hermes and more, plus image generation, embeddings, speech and private web search. All open-weight, so nothing can be d...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Payment | ||
| Pay with (differs)same for all |
TAO
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
We accept 25+ payment methods via Stripe including crypto, cards, and bank transfers. We also accept payments in TAO and Bittensor alpha tokens, and for enterprise customers, we can arrange custom pay...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
USDC
docs.libertai.io checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
docs.libertai.io
Wording at the source
Each request is paid individually with a USDC transaction on Base, signed with your wallet's private key.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Payment chains (differs)same for all |
not published
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
"We accept payment through Stripe (including cards, bank transfers, and other methods Stripe supports) and through supported blockchain deposits, including Bittensor (TAO)."Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 12 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Base
docs.libertai.io checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
docs.libertai.io
Wording at the source
A wallet private key with USDC on Base (chain ID 8453)Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Other payment methodssame for all |
card, bank transfer
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
We accept 25+ payment methods via Stripe including crypto, cards, and bank transfers. We also accept payments in TAO and Bittensor alpha tokens, and for enterprise customers, we can arrange custom pay...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
card, bank transfer
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
Bank card or bank transfer, through our payment service provider. Card data does not pass through our servers.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Balance can be frozensame for all |
Yes
chutes.ai checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
16.3 Effect. When your account ends, your right to use the Platform ends. Any unused prepaid balance is forfeited, except where the law requires a refund or where we terminate your account for conveni...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 10 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| Prices | ||
| Price per month (differs)same for all |
not applicable
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Monthly plans are no longer sold on chutes.ai. If you already have one, it stays active until the end of your current billing period and then does not renew. After that, your usage is billed pay-as-yo...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
8.00 EUR
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
€8/moChecked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean?
20.00 EUR
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
€20/moChecked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean?
100.00 EUR
libertai.io checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
€100/moChecked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Price per yearsame for all |
not applicable
chutes.ai checked 7 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Billing is pay-as-you-go: top up your account balance and pay only for what you use (per-token rates for hosted models, per-second GPU time for Private Chutes), with no subscription and no minimum com...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 7 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
|
| API: Llama 3.3 70B per 1M output tokenssame for all |
not applicable
chutes.ai checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Discover and compare all 30 public models on Chutes. Each model page lists its pricing and how to call it through the API.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
not applicable
docs.libertai.io checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
docs.libertai.io
Wording at the source
| Model | Input | Cached input | Output | |---|---|---|---| | Qwen3.6-35B-A3B | $0.15 / 1M tokens | — | $0.50 / 1M tokens | | Qwen3.8-27B | $0.15 / 1M tokens | — | $0.50 / 1M tokens | | Qwen3.8-27B (T...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| API: gpt-oss-120b per 1M output tokenssame for all |
not applicable
chutes.ai checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Discover and compare all 30 public models on Chutes. Each model page lists its pricing and how to call it through the API.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
not applicable
docs.libertai.io checked 16 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
docs.libertai.io
Wording at the source
| Model | Input | Cached input | Output | |---|---|---|---| | Qwen3.6-35B-A3B | $0.15 / 1M tokens | — | $0.50 / 1M tokens | | Qwen3.8-27B | $0.15 / 1M tokens | — | $0.50 / 1M tokens | | Qwen3.8-27B (T...Checked Verified Check overdue · last 16 Nov 2026 Add this value? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
| Trust | ||
| Support channelssame for all |
e-mail
chutes.ai checked 17 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
chutes.ai
Wording at the source
Chutes Global Corp. 2810 N Church St., Suite 89723 Wilmington, Delaware 19802 United States Privacy and legal requests: <[email protected]>General support: <[email protected]>Checked Verified Check overdue · last 17 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
e-mail
libertai.io checked 15 Nov 2026
Source and check
Source
libertai.io
Wording at the source
Any complaint may be sent to<[email protected]>. We endeavor to respond within thirty days.Checked Verified Check overdue · last 15 Nov 2026 Value wrong? Unchanged since 7 Nov 2026 What does [s] mean? |
Values of the chosen variant; without a choice the entry variant (first in the provider's order).
Early warning
Watch both AI services
One mail when something changes at Chutes · LibertAI: promotions and bonuses as well as warnings and incidents.